Behind the Polished Glass: A Critical Look at Apple in 2025

Apple in 2025: The Empire of Elegance or a Fortress of Control?

Apple Inc. is a household name, a design icon, and a staple in classrooms, offices, and pockets around the world. Yet as the company breaks into new product categories and courts record profits, it’s increasingly facing criticism—not from fringe voices, but from global regulators, developers, and civil rights organizations.

Here’s a grounded critique of Apple’s current business practices across its ecosystem, policies, and global footprint.

⸻

1. The App Store Tollbooth

Apple’s App Store rules remain a major flashpoint. Developers are required to use Apple’s in-app payment system, which takes a 15% to 30% cut. Alternatives are prohibited.
• In the Epic v. Apple case, internal communications revealed the company strategized on how to keep users “locked in” to the Apple ecosystem.
• The U.S. court ruled partially in Apple’s favor but mandated the company allow links to outside payment systems—Apple delayed enforcement pending appeal.
• In 2022, the Netherlands fined Apple €50 million over non-compliance with dating app payment alternatives.

Why it matters: This practice impacts app pricing, developer profits, and innovation across digital services.

⸻

2. Right to Repair: Progress or PR?

In response to global pressure, Apple launched its “Self Service Repair” program in 2021, allowing users to order genuine parts. But the program’s complexity and high costs make it impractical for the average consumer.
• Tools can cost up to $1,200 for a single repair kit.
• iFixit routinely rates Apple devices low on repairability (e.g., M1 MacBook Air: 4/10).
• Device pairing with Apple servers restricts the use of aftermarket or salvaged parts.

Bottom line: Repair rights are expanding—slowly—but Apple is still guarding its hardware behind technical and legal walls.

⸻

3. Privacy: The Marketing and the Reality

Apple’s privacy ads are everywhere. Its ATT (App Tracking Transparency) feature significantly changed mobile advertising—but it’s not as clean-cut as it seems.
• Meta (Facebook) estimated a $10 billion revenue hit due to ATT.
• At the same time, Apple’s own ad network gained market share.
• In China, Apple stores iCloud data on state-run servers managed by Guizhou-Cloud Big Data, raising concerns about government access.

Verdict: Apple protects user privacy—unless that stance conflicts with business priorities or local law compliance.

⸻

4. Censorship in Authoritarian Markets

Apple complies with censorship rules in countries like China and Russia to maintain market access.
• In 2017, Apple removed VPN apps in China.
• In 2019, the company pulled the HKmap.live app used by Hong Kong protestors after Chinese media criticism.
• Thousands of apps are removed annually at the request of foreign governments.

Impact: Apple’s values on free speech are geographically selective, shaped by regional laws and market interests.

⸻

5. Innovation or Iteration?

Critics argue that Apple’s pace of innovation has slowed. While the company leads in custom silicon (M1–M3 chips), its consumer product lines have become less revolutionary.
• iPhone’s design has changed minimally since the iPhone X in 2017.
• The Apple Vision Pro headset launched in 2024 but saw limited adoption due to cost and lack of mainstream applications.
• The most significant updates in recent years have been performance boosts—not new paradigms.

Conclusion: Apple is investing in chip technology, but hasn’t delivered a cultural tech shift since the Apple Watch.

⸻

6. Under the Microscope: Antitrust Scrutiny

The global spotlight is on Apple’s dominance:
• U.S. DOJ Lawsuit (2024): Alleges that Apple illegally monopolized smartphone markets by restricting third-party app stores, browsers, and messaging services.
• EU Digital Markets Act (DMA): Requires Apple to allow sideloading and third-party app stores. Apple began compliance only in the EU—not globally.
• Spotify, Epic, and Tile have all filed formal complaints citing anti-competitive practices.

Forecast: Apple is heading into a decade of regulatory headwinds, especially around platform openness and user choice.

⸻

Final Thoughts: Course Correction or Continued Control?

Apple remains a titan of technology, admired for its product quality, user experience, and brand loyalty. But as it tightens control over its ecosystem and selectively upholds its principles, questions grow louder: Is this stewardship—or dominance?

As global regulators and consumers push back, Apple’s ability to balance business interests with openness and ethics will define its next chapter.

⸻

Tags: #Apple #AppStore #Antitrust #RightToRepair #Privacy #TechNews2025 #Censorship